fix: fresh facts can clarify a reopened contradictory report once, with tools disabled #459

Merged
karsten merged 1 commit from fix/reopened-report-fresh-fact-clarification into main 2026-11-14 11:12:18 +00:00
Owner

Real original559dbf4d still retains an explicitly reopened contradictory historical blocked report. Even after actual installed live positive/negative/failure receipts are supplied, uncertain classifier judgment refuses both productive continuation and any opportunity for its worker to restate new facts. This must NOT be solved by lowering confidence or inventing completion.

Narrow host-only reporting path: only an explicitly reopenedReviewOnly report + strictly newer parent decision + uncertain semantic verdict (or continue) may use existing reportOnly clarification once. runTurn reportOnly disables all tools; no reconciliation/replay of the effectful old transcript. Persist correction/reportOnly before turn; preserve task/effects/counters/scope. NO trigger on technical failure, blocked/waiting, question/stop/expiry; no automatic repeated clarification. New report still requires independent completion judgment. Failed required acceptance remains blocked.

Actual strategy/store/Dispatcher tests cover uncertain=>honest completed restatement + independent approval, uncertain=>still blocked report (must not complete even if reviewer says completed), and blocked/waiting/technical refusal controls. Baseline025276a fails both needed clarification cases, passes5 controls; fixed7/7. Full2507pass/1existingSkip; typecheck/build/diff-check green. No production ledgers hand-edited, model/provider substitution, confidence lowering, or replacement business writer. Existing broad-scope or manual holds untouched. Protected exact-head CI only.

Real original559dbf4d still retains an explicitly reopened contradictory historical blocked report. Even after actual installed live positive/negative/failure receipts are supplied, uncertain classifier judgment refuses both productive continuation and any opportunity for its worker to restate new facts. This must NOT be solved by lowering confidence or inventing completion. Narrow host-only reporting path: only an explicitly reopenedReviewOnly report + strictly newer parent decision + uncertain semantic verdict (or continue) may use existing reportOnly clarification once. runTurn reportOnly disables all tools; no reconciliation/replay of the effectful old transcript. Persist correction/reportOnly before turn; preserve task/effects/counters/scope. NO trigger on technical failure, blocked/waiting, question/stop/expiry; no automatic repeated clarification. New report still requires independent completion judgment. Failed required acceptance remains blocked. Actual strategy/store/Dispatcher tests cover uncertain=>honest completed restatement + independent approval, uncertain=>still blocked report (must not complete even if reviewer says completed), and blocked/waiting/technical refusal controls. Baseline025276a fails both needed clarification cases, passes5 controls; fixed7/7. Full2507pass/1existingSkip; typecheck/build/diff-check green. No production ledgers hand-edited, model/provider substitution, confidence lowering, or replacement business writer. Existing broad-scope or manual holds untouched. Protected exact-head CI only.
fix: allow one tool-free reopened-report clarification after fresh parent facts
All checks were successful
decision-interface-ci / full-validation (pull_request) Successful in 2m52s
e87654bcad
Sign in to join this conversation.
No reviewers
No labels
No milestone
No project
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference
harness/core!459
No description provided.